Current:Home > MarketsThe CDC may be reconsidering its COVID isolation guidance -Finovate
The CDC may be reconsidering its COVID isolation guidance
View
Date:2025-04-17 05:14:46
The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention may soon drop its isolation guidance for people with COVID-19. The planned change was reported in The Washington Post on Tuesday, attributed to several unnamed CDC officials.
Currently, people who test positive are advised to stay home for at least five days to reduce the chances of spreading the coronavirus to others. The unnamed officials told the Post that the agency will advise people to rely on symptoms instead. If a person doesn't have a fever and the person's symptoms are mild or resolving, they could still go to school or work. These changes could come as early as April.
The CDC hasn't yet confirmed the report. In an email, an agency spokesperson wrote that the CDC has "no updates to COVID guidelines to announce at this time. We will continue to make decisions based on the best evidence and science to keep communities healthy and safe."
Some states — California and Oregon — have already implemented similar guidelines.
If this change takes place, it shouldn't be interpreted to mean that COVID-19 is less contagious, says Jennifer Nuzzo, an epidemiologist and director of the Pandemic Center at Brown University School of Public Health.
"The science of COVID has not changed," Nuzzo says. If you test positive for COVID-19, you're likely contagious for a few days at least and risk spreading the coronavirus to others.
The policy change under consideration may be a reflection of the fact that the impacts of spreading COVID-19 are less consequential than they used to be, at least from a public health perspective. Deaths and hospitalizations went up this winter, but nowhere near as high as they did in previous years. In fact, hospitals were mostly OK — not overwhelmed — this virus season.
Changing the guidance may reflect the reality that many Americans, who weren't necessarily following it. Isolation "is really hard, and it takes a lot of work," says Dr. Anand Parekh, chief medical adviser at the Bipartisan Policy Center. He was on day nine of COVID when he spoke to NPR and had spent the first five days isolating at home. He worked, ate and slept alone to avoid exposing his family members, including three young children.
"For a lot of people, it's not possible — how they live, where they live, how many people are in the household, their jobs — whether they have paid leave, whether they could work virtually," he says.
In addition, testing is more expensive and harder to access than it used to be, so people may not even know they have COVID-19, let alone take steps to isolate, Parekh says.
Still, even if many people ignore the current guidance, Jessica Malaty Rivera, an epidemiologist and communications adviser to the de Beaumont Foundation, says the federal government's public health advice should be guiding people, and not the other way around.
"It's like saying, well, people aren't really wearing a seat belt, so I guess we can say seat belts don't matter," she says. "That kind of defeats the purpose of providing evidence-based information — that's still the responsibility of public health to do that."
And a change in CDC guidance could make a big difference for workplace policies, public health experts say. If the CDC no longer recommends staying home for a week with COVID-19, workers may be forced to go into work while still sick. They might spread the coronavirus to others.
And it makes it harder on people who are especially vulnerable: individuals who are very young, very old, immunocompromised or with underlying medical conditions.
"This could actually increase COVID and long COVID cases and, to a certain extent, probably illness among high-risk individuals and thus hospitalizations and deaths," Parekh says, though he notes that evidence from California and Oregon, both states that have stopped recommending five-day isolation periods, has so far been inconclusive.
If the guidance change goes through, the CDC will be effectively treating COVID-19 more like flu, says Nuzzo. But she and other health experts wonder whether that's the right model, given that the status quo of influenza results in many illnesses and deaths.
"While it may make sense for us to kind of harmonize our policies to not just be COVID specific" and address all respiratory pathogens, Nuzzo says, "it doesn't mean that there aren't still risks to people posed by these pathogens."
Malaty Rivera points out that it has never been a good idea to go to work or school with an active flu infection, but it used to be the norm for many people to show their dedication to work. "We didn't value rest and isolation and quarantine," she notes.
Given the risks to vulnerable people and the risk of long COVID, "I think people forget the fact that it's not OK to be moving around when you're infectious," she says. "We can't go back to ignoring those who are immunocompromised, those who are too young or too old and rely on protecting themselves through community protection."
veryGood! (56879)
Related
- As Trump Enters Office, a Ripe Oil and Gas Target Appears: An Alabama National Forest
- Derek Hough Shares Update on Wife Hayley Erbert’s Health After Skull Surgery
- Jonathan Majors begged accuser to avoid hospital, warning of possible ‘investigation,’ messages show
- Drinks are on him: Michigan man wins $160,000 playing lottery game at local bar
- This was the average Social Security benefit in 2004, and here's what it is now
- A ‘soft landing’ or a recession? How each one might affect America’s households and businesses
- 11 dead in clash between criminal gang and villagers in central Mexico
- How a top economic adviser to Biden is thinking about inflation and the job market
- Off the Grid: Sally breaks down USA TODAY's daily crossword puzzle, Hi Hi!
- With no supermarket for residents of Atlantic City, New Jersey and hospitals create mobile groceries
Ranking
- Jamie Foxx reps say actor was hit in face by a glass at birthday dinner, needed stitches
- Biden thanks police for acting during UNLV shooting, renews calls for gun control measures
- Polish truck drivers are blocking the border with Ukraine. It’s hurting on the battlefield
- Russian athletes allowed to compete as neutral athletes at 2024 Paris Olympics
- Newly elected West Virginia lawmaker arrested and accused of making terroristic threats
- FTC opens inquiry of Chevron-Hess merger, marking second review this week of major oil industry deal
- Selena Gomez Congratulates Angel Spring Breakers Costar Ashley Benson On Her Pregnancy
- Utah attorney general drops reelection bid amid scrutiny about his ties to a sexual assault suspect
Recommendation
'We're reborn!' Gazans express joy at returning home to north
Think twice before scanning a QR code — it could lead to identity theft, FTC warns
Texas teen struck, killed by semi after getting off school bus; driver charged with homicide
A ‘soft landing’ or a recession? How each one might affect America’s households and businesses
Off the Grid: Sally breaks down USA TODAY's daily crossword puzzle, Triathlon
Report: Deputies were justified when they fired at SUV that blasted through Mar-a-Lago checkpoint
Ryan O’Neal, star of ‘Love Story,’ ‘Paper Moon,’ ‘Peyton Place’ and ‘Barry Lyndon,’ dies at 82
Fatal shooting by police in north Mississippi is under state investigation